NGC Registry

Collection Manager >

1958 P and D Franklins.

Category:  Toned Coins
Owner:  SkyMan
Last Modified:  2/7/2013
Set Description
I was born in 1958 and have enjoyed collecting both proof and mint set Franklins from that year. While this set is predominantly about toned Franklins I love cameos also, so there are a couple of those included too.

There are 14 dates in the Franklin proof cameo series. 1958 is a tough year for cameo Franklins. The last I checked it was the 6th toughest date to get a PCGS DCAM in and the 4th toughest date to get an NGC UCAM in.

Many circulation strike Franklins have some sort of toning. Generally the toning ranges from unappealing to ugly. However there are a certain amount of Franklins that tone up nicely, probably most commonly with mint set toning. Luckily 1958 mintsets produced some of the nicest toned Franklins in the whole 35 coin MS series.

Set Goals
Birthyear Franklins.

Slot Name
Origin/Country
Item Description
Full Grade
Owner Comments
Pics
View Coin 41106 United States 50C 58 P PCGS MS 65 FBL 1958 P mint Franklins with FBL are surprisingly difficult to find. Images by Laura DeFalco.
View Coin 3410 United States 50C 1958 PCGS MS 65 Images by Shane Canup.
View Coin 42410 United States 50C 1958 D PCGS MS 64 FBL There is a substantial ding going N to S on Ben's cheek, hence the 64. OTOH the ding is toned over so it is not really noticeable. I've seen a LOT of '58-D Franklins. This is unquestionably one of, if not the prettiest, I've ever seen. It has mind melting color. Images by Shane Canup.
View Coin 31804* United States 50C 1958 D NGC MS 66 Pink is a very rare color for Frankies, but there is no question this is NT. Arguably my favorite coin from 1958. Images by Bob Campbell.
View Coin 31804*FBL United States 50C 1958 D NGC MS 66 FBL The image is by Laura DeFalco and the 2nd by LucyBop.
View Coin 2106P United States 50C 1958 PCGS PF 67 UC There was only one 1958 die that made MONSTER deep cameo coins. It is estimated that only 10 to 20 coins were made with ultimate cameo contrast. I started collecting cameo Frankies in the late 1980's. My birthyear is 1958 so I have continually strived to upgrade the representative coin for this date. It took me until 2006, but I finally found a Frankie from this top die. The dot on the cheek does not exist in reality, it is an artifact of imaging.
View Coin 2106N United States 50C 1958 NGC PF 67 UC Clean enough to 68. Images by Bruce Lee.
View Coin 32906 United States 50C 1958 D PCGS MS 66 FBL A MONSTER toner. My PCGS Avatar coin. Images by Bob Campbell.
View Coin 42007*6 United States 50C 1958 D NGC MS 66 Obverse of a mint set pair, slabbed as a pair. Images by LucyBop.
View Coin 42007 United States 50C 1958 D NGC MS 65 Reverse of a mint set pair, slabbed as a pair. Images by LucyBop.
View Coin 52907 United States 50C 1958 NGC MS 66 FBL I bought this one sight unseen figuring that NGC is tough on FBL. Unfortunately when I got it I realized that there is NO WAY this should be a FBL. While the coin does have a reedmark on Ben's head, on the whole I agree with the 66 grade as it is quite clean otherwise. While I'm bummed about the FBL, the coin is flat out gorgeous otherwise, so that's why I'm including it in this set. The images are by Bob Campbell.
View Coin 8207 United States 50C 1958 D NGC MS 67 FBL A technically clean 67 obverse, with beautiful toning as "frosting" on top. The reverse, while toned on the periphery, is basically white. It is nice too, but has a few more nicks than the obverse and I'd grade it a 66. The images are by Bob Campbell.
View Coin 12207 United States 50C 1958 PCGS MS 67 While graded a 67 by PCGS personally technically I'd grade this coin a 65/65+ obverse and a 66+/67- reverse. On the other hand it certainly has the eye appeal of a 67, with stunning iridescent royal blue and gold toning... the visually most arresting 1958-P I've ever seen. It is argueably a FBL, I'll probably send it in for a designation review at some point in time. This coin was imaged by Bob Campbell.

To follow or send a message to this user,
please log in