Owner Comments:
Ecuador - 1919 (Providence Mint) - 5 Centavos - (KM #63, EC #132) - Production Mintage: 12,000,000
Exact specimen mintage: unknown
History
These coins were minted for the "Republica Del Ecuador" by the Providence Mint, a division of Gorham Manufacturing Company in Providence Rhode Island. Known primarily for producing high-quality sterling silverware and holloware, they also produced silver and base metal coins for several foreign countries including Ecuador, Serbia, and Cuba. The most notable of these are the several varieties of 1897 Cuban "Souvenir Pesos", and the 1898 Cuban Peso. It is interesting to note that the engravers at the Providence mint did the best job depicting the steamship
Guayas, the Guayas River and the snow capped Chimborazo volcano at the center of the coat of arms. They are probably the only engravers to correctly depict a Caduceus as the main mast of the ship.
Varieties
I became interested in this "one year type" in 2004, and I have acquired quite a few of these coins over the years since. Krause & Mishler identifiy three main varieties, but I have come to realize that there are many more significant die varieties than that. The ones that everyone knows are all linked to the configuration of berries directly to the left of the
C in
CENTAVOS on the reverse. They are as follows:
- 3 berries to left of C on reverse. Most common variety.
- 4 berries tightly grouped to left of C on reverse. (aka 4 Berries tight) Sub-varieties exist.
- 4 berries loosely grouped to left of C on reverse. (aka 4 Berries loose) This variety is extremely rare.
In addition to these, I have noticed that there are at least three sub-varieties of the grouping of the 4 berries tight variety. They exist in square and diamond configurations and there are two types of diamond patterns. The diamond pattern being much more common than the square pattern. Varieties also exist in the style and positioning of the letters in the word
CENTAVOS.
All of the focus has been on the varieties exhibited on the reverse, but there are very noticeable varieties on the obverse as well. The four main characteristics of the obverse that are easily identifiable are:
- The overall style of the design (Refined or Crude)
- The number and style of tail feathers on the condor perched atop the coat of arms.
- The size and position of the sun just below the condor.
- The presence or absence of the backstay on the mizzenmast of the ship.
Combine all of the obverse and reverse varieties, and one could define a collection similar to all of the varieties known for the 1878 8TF Morgan Dollar!
Based on the large number of die varieties and style of the design, I have come to the conclusion that there was probably no master hub used and that each die was very likely hand cut.
Until this coin, NGC had certified 4 of the 3 Berry variety coins as "Specimen", but I had only seen photos of two of them which had appeared in Heritage auctions over the years. I acquired this coin because it appeared very well struck and also appeared to have cameo devices, but I never imagined it would garner an
SP grade. Needless to say, I was quite pleased with the grade, but I still do not know exactly what distinguishes these specimen coins from the normal production strike coins since not all of the specimen pieces were struck from the same obverse die. I most certainly intend to ask NGC though the next time I go to the ANA convention..
This coin
This particular coin is exceptionally well struck with very pleasing cameo devices. As of this revision, NGC has graded only 4 others as Specimen, 3 at SP63, and 1 at SP67. This is the one and only example to receive a cameo designation at SP65CA. PCGS has graded only one, but with a Proof designation as PR66. Having studied two of the other NGC specimen coins, I find it interesting that they do not all have the same obverse characteristics, which means that these specimen pieces were not all struck from the same die. So exactly what does it mean to be a specimen coin? For additional high resolution images, check out the verification page:
NGC 2882769-002
Obverse characteristics are:
Overall design: ............Refined
Condor Tail Feathers: 3, even
Sun Size: ......................Small, slightly above center
Mizzenmast Backstay: No
Date acquired: 9/20/2020 (raw coin)
Date graded: 8/19/2023 (self submitted to NGC)
References:
Seppa, Dale and Anderson, Michael,
the COINS of ECUADOR (second edition), Almanzar's Coins of the World, San Antonio, 1973.
Rev. 4/18/2024